July 15, 2009

What's the matter with the WSJ?

Thomas Frank, most famous for insulting the most middle of Middle American states, goes after Sarah Palin in his WSJ column:

This is no small thing, mind you. The piling-up of petty complaints is an important aspect of conservative movement culture. For those who believe that American life consists of the trampling of Middle America by the "elites" -- that our culture is one big insult to the pious and the patriotic and the traditional -- Sarah Palin's long list of unfair and disrespectful treatment is one of her most attractive features. Like Oliver North, Robert Bork, and Clarence Thomas, she is known not for her ideas but as a martyr, a symbol of the culture-war crimes of the left.
But of course. She has no ideas. I mean, just to pick one of her non-ideas, she has never advocated expanded oil drilling as a way to make America more independent from foreign sources of oil.

Frank goes on to claim that Palin was set up as "a candidate on a cross" for the kind of rubes he has based his career on:
Resentment was, for example, the most-noticed theme in her famous speech at the Republican convention in September, when she introduced herself to America by taking umbrage at those Democrats who "seem to look down on" small-town ways.
Um...

Frank belittles Palin's treatment at the hands of the MSM and Democrats (bIrm) as having a thin skin. Okay, let's suppose that's true. But let's ask him a few questions...

Since you're a public figure, what with your bestselling book and your column in the WSJ and all, would you be happy if a lot of people throughout the MSM repeatedly suggested that you were stupid?

If someone was to suggest that you had behaved in an unethical manner while writing your books or columns without any basis, would you be upset?

If MSM organizations flew teams into your hometown to investigate your every last move, would you feel like you were being singled out?

If a bunch of batshit crazy conspiracy theorists scrutinized the birth of your kids and publicized their insane theories, is that something you might object to?

(thanks to eddie)

Posted by: Sean M. at 04:43 AM | Comments (5) | Add Comment
Post contains 369 words, total size 2 kb.

1 Yeah, because We Rubes are simply making up all the crap that was said about her.  Yup.  Totally made up.  Hey, here's a nutty idea, if all y'all in the press didn't savage her mercilessly, then she wouldn't be a martyr.  Why, that's an idea just crazy enough to work!

Posted by: alexthechick at July 15, 2009 08:08 AM (SHHaV)

2
A really stupid perspective. Palin's popularity is derived from her actions as Alaska's governor, and her words as a staunch conservative (which is why Fred! continues to be popular). And being dismissive of the incessant train of outrageous accusations levied against her indicates a willful blindness.

The mere fact that she is still a news figure, 8 months after the election, shows how obsessed the news media is with her. She's in the news more than Joe Biden, and her coverage is rarely complimentary.

Posted by: geoff at July 15, 2009 08:43 AM (/yRrx)

3 She is still a great national figure.  Say, where's that old guy?  Has he crawled back into his hole yet.  I've still got that money I promised for any conservative who will primary his a$$.

Posted by: TimothyJ at July 15, 2009 09:00 AM (IKKIf)

4 Frank is the Journal’s house liberal, and has a reputation for shading his “facts” to reinforce the impression he wants to leave with his readers. (The WSJ editors appear to let their opinion columnists write pretty much what they want, without challenging half-truths or fallacious reasoning. Which actually makes for weaker arguments, but there you go...)

Anyway, when it comes to giving advice to Republicans, Frank is about as worth paying attention to as Peggy Noonan. 

Posted by: Old Grouch at July 15, 2009 09:58 AM (UURCL)

5 Does Frank still beat his wife?  And does she still take it up the squeaker on the first date?

Posted by: thirteen28 at July 15, 2009 01:26 PM (s8N54)

Hide Comments | Add Comment






21kb generated in 0.0501 seconds; 67 queries returned 154 records.
Powered by Minx 1.1.2-pink.