September 16, 2009

This seems like a bad deal for gays...

In reading the bloviation of weed-smoking weathervane Andrew Sullivan (no link because his words, like radiation, are bad for brain tissue) I began to ponder something I'd never really considered:  should gays, as a group, be for or against nationalized single-payer health care?
 
I think they should be against it.  Here's my reasoning:  given the prevailing cultural realities in the US, under most politically feasible schemes which allocate finite resources to the needs of many, gays will almost surely end up getting the short end of the stick.
 
Here's my reasoning:
 
Gay males are disproportionately affected by the HIV/AIDS virus.  This requires costly drugs and treatment to control.  People who contract HIV/AIDS represent a pharmaceutical black hole into which the plan will shovel money.  But actuarially, there's no real reason to do this: they're going to die sooner rather than later, their remaining years will be increasingly worse, they typically have no dependents to support, and they can't procreate.  So their quality of life adjusted years and overall "benefit to society" numbers will both be low.
 
Imagine a 50-year-old single male who contracts HIV: do you think he gets costly drugs, or do you suppose they go to a 20-year-old single woman who has contracted Lupus?  Which do you think society and politicians will naturally favor?
 
I think we all know who'd head for the "take an aspirin and die in the morning" list.
 
Second, gays as a group should tend to be more affluent than other members of society (I would think, but could be wrong).  They are certainly more likely to be in the under-30 uninsured with no family category than the average person.  So they can expect to pay more for the system than other people, as it's their funds which will make the whole scheme solvent.
 
So they can expect to pay to help the 20-year old mother with Lupus, too.  Thanks!
 
Third, those gays who want to procreate (and I suppose there are some) would need to be artificially inseminated (well, not really, but for monogomous lesbians this seems the most practical choice).  But this requires doctors and nurses to do.  Do you suppose that the government has the political will to make sure that this service is given out evenly, or do you suppose government will cave under pressure from family rights groups who insist that traditional couples get first dibs on treatment and support for fertility issues? 
 
So let's review:  higher payments for gays, coupled with reduced access to services, along with a possible scenario where they're denied treatment because they're actuarially less valuable.
 
I can't see what's in it for gays.  Do I miss something?
 
My advice to gays is this:  just because the Democrats propose it doesn't mean it's in your best interests.  Remember:  just like Miss California, the president supported Proposition 8.  This means he is not necessarily your friend.
 
No matter what Perez Hilton and Andrew Sullivan might think.

Posted by: plebian at 04:37 PM | Comments (5) | Add Comment
Post contains 498 words, total size 3 kb.

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
15kb generated in CPU 0.1125, elapsed 0.24 seconds.
62 queries taking 0.2321 seconds, 145 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.